Let's Make a Map!: A Comparison of Current Web Mapping Libraries

Nick Janzen

Plan a call on this topic with Dominique GoesIn the current market there are lots of web mapping libraries available. There are so many options available that it’s hard to pick one that best fits your wishes. This becomes harder as the demand for online web maps rapidly grows. In the coming weeks we will compare the five biggest currently available web mapping libraries.

Let’s first state the possibilities of the currently available libraries in their latest release (as of February 2019):

  Esri ArcGIS API for Javascript Leaflet Cesium OpenLayers Google Maps Javascript API
WMS supported
WMTS supported

(plug-in exists)
WFS supported
✘ 
(plug-in exists)
GeoJson supported

(plug-in exists)
KML supported

(plug-in exists)
Feature Service supported

(plug-in exists)

(plug-in exists)
GeoRSS supported
3D supported

(plug-in exists)

(plug-in exists)
Basemaps included
Built-in Geocoding Methods

(plug-in exists)
Built-in Security Methods
Proprietary
Cost
Free if app uses ArcGIS Online or ArcGIS Enterprise services
Free
Free
Free
Free for a small amount of requests
           
Summary
A library tightly integrated within the ArcGIS ecosystem with tools familiar to GIS professionals.
A small library that is easy to start with that accomplishes most of the basic web map tasks with a large plug-in library.
A library focused on creating stunning 3D visualizations.
A library with all the features ever needed for a full fledge web map with a strong and supportive community.
A library that provides a familiar user experience with both the map and included widgets.

In practice: what is the best library for you?

When you start creating a web map you have to first choose which of the available libraries fits best for your purpose. It’s often hard to find one library that combines all of your wanted features. My advice: don’t rush this decision. Create a list prioritizing the most important features,  interview users, use user stories and use every possible measure to ensure you pick the library that best fits your needs. Much like a foundation of a house, it’s difficult to remove a mapping library from your application once you have started.

How to meet all of your requirements with (only) one library?

As said, no single one library is capable of having all features. If your selected library is missing that one feature more often than not there’s a workaround. Many solutions are documented online and some others have to be created manually. If you need any advice on this, please feel free to contact me.

In the coming weeks I’ll show some ‘how to’s’ and the result with the different libraries. Please follow Tensing on LinkedIn to see any new post in your timeline.

Plan a call on this topic with Dominique Goes

 

Meer weten over dit onderwerp?

Plan een sparringssessie met een van ons experts
Kennishub

Ontdek meer over dit onderwerp

5 mythes en 5 waarheden over de integratie tussen BIM en GISArcGIS,ESRI,ArcGIS Pro,GIS,blog,BIM,Inzicht

Succesvolle lancering 3D GeoViewerInnovation,GIS,Tensing,blog,BIM

Gebruiker-centraal ontwikkelen in ArcGIS ProArcGIS Pro,GIS,Consultancy,blog

Snellere verwerking van data die je mobiel inwintArcGIS,GIS,Mobiele data,blog,Inzicht

Snellere vergunning voor architecten dankzij geografische informatieInnovation,GIS,Geo-ICT,blog,BIM,Inzicht,3D

Over ons

Tensing maakt GIS-technologie toegankelijk en toepasbaar. Onze consultants realiseren state-of-the-art oplossingen op basis van Esri ArcGIS en Safe Software FME.

Blijf op de hoogte

Esri ArcGIS

Met Esri maken wij kaarten, stimuleren we samenwerking en analyseren we data. Zo heb jij altijd inzicht in de actuele situatie.

Safe Software FME

Met FME verbind je eenvoudig honderden applicaties, transformeer je data op oneindig veel manieren en automatiseer je workflows.
© 2019 Tensing | Privacy Policy | Cookie Policy